• About
  • Join
  • Events
  • Resources
+1 847 692 6378

325 West Touhy Avenue 
Park Ridge, IL 60068 USA

Contact us

Helpful Links

  • For Companies
  • MDRT Store
  • MDRT Foundation
  • MDRT Academy
  • MDRT Center for Field Leadership
  • Media Room

MDRT Chapter Sites

  • Korea
  • Japan
  • Chinese Taiwan

Copyright 2025 Million Dollar Round Table®

DisclaimerPrivacy

During a recent meeting of the Income Replacement Task Force at MDRT headquarters, Roger A. Seim, MSFS, CLU, a 36-year MDRT member from Maple Grove, Minnesota, posed this scenario: You have a good relationship with a client and learn they plan to replace a product they have with you. What would you do?

These are three insights offered by MDRT members on the panel.


1. “Rather than going and replacing a product, they should look at augmenting what they already have. Ethical issues could arise if the client cancels a policy and doesn’t qualify for a new one with the new company because they have to qualify all over again medically. Then the new advisor could be held liable, and the client won’t have coverage.”
— Alphonso B. Franco, RHU, RCIS, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada, 23-year member

2. “I ask the client to send me what he is being offered so I can analyze it carefully and help them understand the objective differences between the policy he has versus the new product. I then explain to the client what the replacement means and its implications for the policy owner.”
— Dorin Roxana Israelian, Buenos Aires, Argentina, 16-year member

3. “Never become defensive. Always be helpful, and put forward your value proposition. Advise the client accordingly on the replacement and wish them the best, but ensure they are aware you’ll always be there with regards to their overall financial planning. And even if they leave, they can drop in again at any time.”
— Kobus Kleyn, CFP, Midrand, South Africa, 5-year member

Matt Pais
Matt Pais
in Round the Table MagazineAug 21, 2017

3 ways to answer clients' replacement requests

Members share various ways to handle an unexpected situation.
Retirement planning
‌
‌

Author(s):

Matt Pais

MDRT senior content specialist